Star Wars Character Encyclopedia: Updated and Expanded.
While books like character encyclopedias are never an
unwelcome addition to my bookshelf, I must admit that I had never expected to receive
this one. In fact, it surprisingly arrived on my doorstep (quite literally)
alongside another book. And, seeing as to how I am a huge Star Wars fan I
welcomed the opportunity to give it a good perusal.
Star Wars Character Encyclopedia: Updated and Expanded, is a
224 page book published by DK Books and authored by Pablo Hidalgo. Its intended
audience is readers ages 7 to 17. The book is, as the name suggests, an updated
version to include new entries that include characters from The Force Awakens.
First, let me begin by establishing that I can understand
what they were trying for here. Believe me. I get it. The whole design was
clearly focused on being a fun little collection of info for kids/young
readers.
With that in mind, it is understandable that this would not
be a comprehensive dossier on all the complex figures that inhabit a galaxy far
far away. It also means that an older reader can expect some simplification as
to wording, grammar and yes – the information itself.
But here is one of the key problems that I found with this
book; they go too far in this aspect of the book’s design. When benign aspects
are repeatedly highlighted such as; ‘this is a belt/belt buckle’ things get
monotonous even to a kid. You can write simple fact based entries for fictional
characters without highlighting things in terms of; look, they have boots! I
mean, come on. Just because your target audience is children doesn’t mean you
have to insult their intelligence.
Furthermore, the art in this book also causes me an issue.
When there is an untold wealth of images and art to draw on from character sketches,
comic panels all the way up to digital artist renderings I have to question the
logic behind decades old grainy vhs screen shots. Because that is what some of
the artwork looks like to me. This is just sad.
I hate speaking ill of any book, especially one that covers
a beloved brand. But this was one that I just found far too many short comings
to ignore. I can applaud the attempt, I really can. However things were poorly
worded at times to be clear to a younger reader, the art was cheap and honestly
things were just way too watered down to retain the inherent value and appeal
that Star Wars has.
I’d have to rate it 2/5 with one point for the effort and
another for the range of material covered. Better art, tighter wording/editing
and a more systematic approach to how the various entries were described would
have gone a long way. A lot of kids will read about one creature and want to
know where it is from etc and then question why the next doesn’t even mention
such information. The devil is in the details and that makes this feel more
like cheaply produced cash grab. This is disappointing given the quality I am
beginning to expect and admire from DK Books.
No comments:
Post a Comment